Resources | Entersekt

Security doesn't lose the sale. Slow security does.

Written by Entersekt | Nov 18, 2026, 10:11:08 AM

For years, checkout authentication has been designed around one assumption: customers hate friction. Every extra step is a reason to leave, so the best experience is the one with nothing in the way.

Ask shoppers, however, and the story changes.

In October 2026, Entersekt surveyed 1,026 U.S. adults who plan to shop online this holiday season. We asked how they feel when their bank steps into a purchase, how long they'll wait for it, and what makes them walk away. The answers point to a different problem, and a more fixable one.

Shoppers are asking you to check

Given the choice during a major online sale, 77.8% of shoppers would rather their bank pause and confirm a legitimate purchase, adding a few seconds of friction, than let purchases through unchecked and risk a fraudulent charge slipping by.

That isn't grudging acceptance. When their bank pauses an unusually large holiday purchase of $500 or more, 48.4% say their first reaction is reassurance. Only 11.8% feel annoyed.

The absence of a check can even unsettle them. Picture a high-value purchase on an unfamiliar website going through instantly with no verification at all:

  • A third of shoppers (33.5%) say that would make them uneasy, wondering whether their bank is actually watching their account.

  • Only 25.3% would feel relieved.

For issuers, this is a valuable kind of permission. Cardholders aren't asking you to disappear. They're asking you to show up when it matters.

The clock is the real constraint

But permission comes with a time limit, and it's short.

We asked how long shoppers would wait for a bank's confirmation step during a limited-time sale before abandoning the purchase or trying another payment method: 29.4% would give up within 30 seconds. 54.4% would give up within a minute. Only 12.4% said they would wait as long as it takes.

That window is already being missed. 39.2% of shoppers abandoned or exited an online purchase in the past 12 months because their bank's approval process took too long or was too complicated, and 16.5% did it more than once. Another 24.0% came close. Just 36.8% say they always complete the approval process.

Put those findings side by side and the real tension is clear. It isn't security versus convenience. It's secure and fast versus secure and slow. Shoppers want the first. Too many still get the second.

Why the cost lands on the issuer

It's tempting to see checkout abandonment as a merchant metric. The data says issuers carry much of the cost.

86.2% of U.S. shoppers pay online most often with a credit or debit card. When a confirmation step stalls and the shopper reaches for a different card, the sale may still happen, but not on yours. The issuer loses the authorization, the interchange, and a measure of top-of-wallet position that is hard to win back during the busiest spending weeks of the year.

Timing makes it worse.

Holiday shopping is front-loaded and concentrated: 55.0% of shoppers plan to complete most of their gift buying before Thanksgiving week, and 21.8% during Cyber Weekend itself. The moments when authentication is under the most load are the same moments when cardholders form their habits for the season.

Measure your step-up like a revenue line

If the check isn't the problem and the delay is, then completion time deserves the same attention as fraud loss.

That starts with measuring the right things:

  • How long does a step-up take, end to end, from the moment it's triggered to the moment the merchant receives an approval?

  • What does that look like at the 95th percentile under peak load, rather than on an average Tuesday?

  • What share of challenged transactions complete, and what share quietly disappear?

  • How many are completed on a different card?

It also means challenging with more precision. Every unnecessary step-up spends some of the cardholder's limited patience. Risk-aware, real-time decisioning lets good customers through on low-risk purchases and saves the challenge for the transactions that genuinely warrant it. When a challenge is needed, the method should be fast, resistant to phishing, and close to where the customer is already buying.

None of this asks issuers to dial down protection. It asks them to deliver protection at the speed cardholders now expect.

The choice that isn't

The industry has spent a long time debating how much security customers will tolerate. The better question is how quickly that security can happen.

Shoppers have answered the first question already: they want their bank looking out for them. What they won't accept is waiting for it. Issuers that close that gap protect more than transactions. They protect their place in the customer's wallet at the moment it's most contested.

Get the full findings

'Safe, sound, and abandoned: The holiday friction paradox' shares the complete data from 1,026 U.S. holiday shoppers, including their experiences with false declines, failed app handoffs, and the SMS habit fraudsters are counting on.